I ended up driving to Saratoga Springs to watch Wrestlemania with my friend Byron. Eventually we were joined by roommate Steve, who was coming off a matinee performance of "Dracula" in Cohoes (seriously). Before continuing, I want to say that it was good to unwind and that it'd been awhile since I'd seen Byron. So in that sense, it was good to catch up and subsequently a good time was had by all in attendance.
As for the product we were presented with? Well...
In the closing moments of his autobiography
Hitman, Bret Hart takes a moment to write that he'll "never forgive Hunter and Shawn for what they did to the business."
Considering what happened with Bret Hart and his tendency to take himself a bit too seriously, people might dismiss the remark as the whinings of a bitter man who is simply upset that he can no longer be part of the business that he grew up on. However, despite what people may think of his motivations, Bret Hart speaks nothing but the truth. The professional wrestling on display tonight in Houston, Texas bears no resemblance to what we grew up on. Or what our parents grew up on. Or even what we were watching just a scant eight to ten years ago.
The reason? Well, being the only game in town has finally caught up to a company that had always shown a strong desire to push barely coordinated, insecure gymrats over people with a true passion for the craft who actually wanted to become good at what they do. For years they've dragged these man-children away from full-body mirrors and thrown them into developmental leagues where, rather than learn from working with seasoned professionals, they tripped over each other and taught themselves irreversible bad habits.
And so that's what WWE has become: a league of old men who won't step out of the way, gymrats who receive praise simply for becoming barely competent at their craft (which is the best they can ever hope for, eg. Randy Orton) and the few hard-working men they have left thrown into clusterf**k matches involving ladders and midgets.
This...is Wrestlemania.
MATCH 1: "Money in the Bank" Ladder Match
RESULT: C.M. Punk over Kofi Kingston, Shelton Benjamin, Christian, Kane, Mark Henry, MVP, and Fit Finlay.
ANALYSIS: This is the clusterf*** I was alluding to. Most of the men involved are good hands who take very stupid risks involving hard falls and high-angle bumps, all for the sake of making a crowd pop in a manner which doesn't get them over or make anybody care about them after the match. It's a match where only the concept gets over rather than any participant, and it was won for the second year in a row by a guy who may be as good as some claim he is but will never draw a dime for WWE.
KID ROCK PERFORMED FOR WHAT SEEMED LIKE A GODDAMN ETERNITY. This was beyond awful. He did four songs and the crowd couldn't have cared less. Because, guess what, it's 2009 and Kid Rock is twelve years past the apex of his popularity (which wasn't all that great to begin with).
MATCH 2: 25 Divas Battle Royal -OR- "How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Santino Marella"
RESULT: Santino Marella in drag wins. After the match he introduces himself as "Santina...Santino's Marella's twin sister. From Italy! Yaaaaaaay!"
ANALYSIS: They built the return of several legendary women's wrestlers, then had all the participants come out at once while Kid Rock sang with no introduction. Then the match was laid out in a manner which ensured even the commentators would have no idea what was going on or who was in the ring at any given moment. Rumor has it Trish Stratus may have been there.
MATCH 3: Chris Jericho vs. Roddy Piper & Jimmy "Superfly" Snuka & Ricky "The Dragon Steamboat
RESULT: Chris Jericho eliminated Piper first, then Snuka, then pinned Steamboat after the latter put up a valiant effort. Then he beat up Flair, only to be KO'ed by Mickey Rourke with the fakest looking knockout punch I've ever seen.
ANALYSIS: This was actually our favorite match of the night, particularly when it got down to Jericho and Steamboat. Seriously, Steamboat worked his fifty-year-old ass off for some great (and believable) near-falls before Jericho won. It's sad that Steamboat still works a better match than most of the WWE roster, but even sadder that even a relatively younger guy like Chris Jericho seems like a relic of a bygone era for the industry. Frank Shamrock came in and sat with Mickey Rourke at ringside and nobody acknowledged him.
MATCH 4: Matt Hardy vs. Jeff Hardy in an "Extreme Rules" Match
RESULT: Matt Hardy wins.
ANALYSIS: It was an okay match I suppose, but nothing we haven't seen from these two before. The announcers sold the idea of two brothers feuding as an awful tragedy, and asked how Matt Hardy could do the sort of things he did to his brother. Unfortunately, this storyline (and match) have already been done before. Not just with other former tag teams, but specifically with Matt and Jeff Hardy. But that's what happens when a wrestling company actually goes out of its way to hire failed sitcom writers with no familiarity with the product to work on their creative team.
MATCH 5: Rey Mysterio vs. JBL in an Intercontinental Title Match
RESULT: Rey Mysterio pinned JBL in 21 seconds to win the title.
ANALYSIS: Obviously done as a joke or rib of some sort, and a frustrated JBL angrily announced "I QUIT!" after the match. He'll most likely be back in a headset to replace Tazz as the color commentator on Smackdown (Tazz left the company this week).
MATCH 6: Shawn Michaels vs. The Undertaker
RESULT: Undertaker wins and preserves his Wrestlemania win streak.
ANALYSIS: Largely predictable fair that people who love Shawn Michaels' asinine cartoon bumps and tired schtick will call a "Match of the Year candidate." Even putting all vitrol for his past misbehavior and politicking aside, the past two years have proven that Shawn Michaels is hands down the most overrated worker of the past ten to fifteen years. He still has some good matches in him, but he's not the untouchable God in the ring that so many seem to think he is. And for as much of a nostalgia pop as he gets when he comes out, there's a reason they don't make any money when he's in the main event spot.
MATCH 7: Edge vs. John Cena vs. The Big Show for the WWE Title
RESULT: John Cena pinned Big Show in decisive fashion to win the WWE Title.
ANALYSIS: Actually not a bad match. As much as people rave about Michaels, few give Cena (who I admittedly used to bury as one of those gymrats) the credit he deserves. The guy works his ass off, and without him to carry them the past five years this company would be in a lot of trouble. Unfortunately, he had to compete with HHH for the top spot on the biggest show of the year, and he lost out despite the fact that he garners much stronger stronger reactions at every stop WWE makes. Speaking of which...
THE HALL OF FAME INDUCTEES WERE INTRODUCED: HOWARD FINKEL, KOKO B. WARE (who I loved but Jesus Christ was he a terrible worker), THE VON ERICHS (accepting was Kevin Von Erich in light of him being the only surviving member of the family...you wish I was joking), TERRY & DORY FUNK, and "STONE COLD" STEVE AUSTIN. Afterwards, Austin drove his ATV around the ring four or five times and drank fifteen beers in the ring. For whatever strange reason, the guy who most consider to be the best promo guy of all time didn't say a single word.
MATCH 8: HHH vs. Randy Orton for the World Heavyweight Championship
RESULT: HHH retains his title by pinning Randy Orton, then growled at a silent audience that couldn't believe WWE actually chose to end Wrestlemania with this match.
ANALYSIS: Seriously, the crowd died during the opening minutes of this match and never came back to life. It actually served as an apt metaphor for the state of the professional wrestling industry and what it's become under the monopolistic fist of Vince McMahon and airtime dominance of his real-life son-in-law, HHH.
I'm sure some apologists will blame the poor crowd reaction on the fact that they didn't have enough of a buffer after the Cena match to calm them down. Two problems with that argument. One, while they didn't stick the women's match in-between to bring the crowd back down like they usually do, they still had the HOF segment and an extended break that included some video packages. Two, that argument essentially breaks down to "HHH and Randy Orton didn't get a good reaction because the crowd doesn't care about them as much as they care about John Cena and Edge."
It's taken awhile for WWE's fans to accept Randy Orton as a main-eventer, but that's all they do - simply accept the role that WWE has forcibly inserted Orton into. They're never going to fully embrace him or demand he be elevated, given more airtime, or made the company's champion. In many ways, the same reasons that Randy Orton will never make them money is why HHH, despite periodically maneuvering himself into the top spot over the course of the past ten years, has never drawn a dime on his own merit.
Both are perfect examples of WWE insisting on making somebody a star rather than letting the crowd make the decision. As a result, we got two men working against each other in the top match of the biggest show of the year while the crowd sat on their hands or left early. Steve Austin once said that HHH never accomplished anything in the industry other than putting a world title on himself and not drawing any money, a point that's hard to argue considering any successful program with HHH in it also involved the two biggest stars in the history of the business (The Rock and Austin) or the most beloved and sympathetic babyface of all-time (Mick Foley).
On his own, HHH is just a dude who has been clever in his political maneuvering but really doesn't provide any financial upside to WWE or any genuine entertainment value. Unfortunately, he's not going anywhere anytime soon and he's positioned himself as Vince McMahon's heir apparent. Fans can only hope that once he decides to retire from a professional wrestling ring, HHH will be freed from the desire to make himself the center of the WWE Universe and use those smarts to make a better wrestling product. The cynic in me, however, knows that there will always be a part of HHH that needs to put himself above the needs of the company and will find a way to overstay his welcome in front of a camera.
I used to love professional wrestling. Now I can only echo two sentiments, one being Bret Hart's and the other being my good friend Miz, who recently remarked to me (via Facebook) that he tried watching RAW last week and in his opinion it's every bit as bad as it was when Shawn Michaels was champion in the mid-90s, when the business nearly died.
It's said that the business is cyclical. But all the premature deaths, tragedies, and eight years of the HHH & Shawn Michaels Show has brought me to the point where I probably won't come around even if there is another resurgence.
And on that note, I sleep.